Arbitration court dismissed part of Kazakhstan's claims against Kashagan

International arbitration rejected Kazakhstan's ~$12 billion claims against Kashagan shareholders.

Arbitration court dismissed part of Kazakhstan's claims against Kashagan

According to Bloomberg, the court found that claims for 2011-2015 costs were filed too late. There is no official confirmation: the Ministry of Energy and the project operator, the North Caspian Operating Company (NCOC) consortium, did not respond to requests, Kursiv.kz writes.

The essence in brief

  • The arbitration rejected Kazakhstan's claims of approximately $12 billion for 2011-2015 costs; they were deemed to have been filed late.
  • In total, Kazakhstan sought the recovery of about $20 billion in disputed costs; about $8 billion in claims remain under consideration.
  • The total amount of claims, including lost profits, exceeds $150 billion.
  • This is a separate dispute from the fine for sulfur amounting to 2.3 trillion tenge, which is being challenged in other courts.

What the arbitration decided

The dispute concerns which costs NCOC shareholders are entitled to recover from produced oil. In April 2023, Kazakhstan filed a lawsuit against NCOC for $13 billion; later the amount grew to $15 billion. The claims concerned violations of tender procedures and incomplete performance of contract work. The total amount of claims was then raised to more than $150 billion, including lost profits.

Now the arbitration, according to sources, has invalidated claims of about $12 billion: the deadline for them has expired. The remaining approximately $8 billion will continue to be considered. The defendants are NCOC shareholders, including ExxonMobil, Eni, Shell, TotalEnergies, KazMunayGas (KMG), CNPC and Inpex. ExxonMobil, Shell, TotalEnergies, KMG and Inpex declined to comment; CNPC and Eni did not immediately respond.

ExxonMobil previously told Kazakhstan that potential investments of $80 billion in expanding Kashagan depend on the arbitration decision. A joint venture with KMG on equal terms is proposed, which would allow production to be raised to 600,000 barrels per day.

Separate dispute over the fine

The decision on costs does not concern the sulfur fine. It amounts to about 2.3 trillion tenge, was issued to the NCOC operator and is being challenged separately. Kazakhstan gave NCOC until July 20, then the Ministry of Justice warned the head of the consortium of criminal liability. After that, forced collection began, property was seized, and in September the collection was suspended but not cancelled. Later Kazakhstan resumed it. NCOC is challenging the fine, including in international proceedings.

What KMG says

KMG Management Board Chairman Askhat Khasenov on October 23 answered a question from Baq.kz about whether the company would have to bear obligations if the court decision on the fine enters into force.

He said: "We are obliged to comply with the law. No one can restrict us in this."

He did not directly say whether KMG would pay. KMG holds 16.88% in the project.

Author's conclusion

$12 billion in claims were rejected because of the filing deadline, not because the costs were recognized as justified. The remaining approximately $8 billion remains the subject of dispute, and the sulfur fine is proceeding through a separate chain of courts.